Pages

Saturday, March 30, 2013

As-Sa’ee al-Mashkoor feeman Waththaqahu al-Jumhoor



As-Sa’ee al-Mashkoor feeman Waththaqahu al-Jumhoor

(السعي المشكور فيمن وثقه الجمهور)

Author: Haafidh Abu Taahir Zubayr Alee Za’ee

Translation & Research by: Raza Hassan

Note: Click on each narrator to open the detailed research about them. Also note that some links are to be updated later, in-shaa-Alaah.

Haafidh Ibn Hajar said: “He is declared Thiqah by the Jumhoor”
[Hadi us-Saari: P. 456]

Ibn Hajar said: “And he is Thiqah according to the Jumhoor…”
[Al-Amaali al-Mutlaqah: 1/54]

Al-Haythami said: “The Majority is upon his Tawtheeq”
[Majma az-Zawaaid: 1/189]
Also see, Faydh al-Qadeer by al-Manaawi (4/471)

Ismaa’eel bin Abi Uways
Al-Nawawi said: “And similarly, Ismaa’eel bin Abi Uways has been weakened by Yahya bin Ma’een and al-Nasaa’ee; however the majority has declared him Thiqah and they have taken evidence from him; and (likewise) Al-Bukhaari and Muslim have taken evidence from him in their Saheehayn”
[Sharh Saheeh Muslim by Nawawi: 14/72 under H. 2094]

Baqiyyah bin al-Waleed
Al-Mundhiri said: “He is Thiqah according to the Jumhoor however he is Mudallis”
[Al-Targheeb wal Tarheeb: 4/568]

Adh-Dhahabi said: “The Jumhoor has declared him Thiqah in what he heard from the Thiqaat”
[Al-Kaashif: 1/106, 107 T. 626]

Ibn Hajar said: “He is Mawthaq according to the Jumhoor”
[Fath al-Baari: 13/355 under H. 7371 - 7355]

Ibn Abdil Haadi said: “He is Thiqah according to the Jumhoor”
[Al-Muharrar fil Hadeeth: 1/173 H. 199]

Ibn al-Mulaqqin said: “The Jumhoor is upon his Tawtheeq as said by Nawawi in his Tahdheeb”
[Khulaasah al-Badar al-Muneer: 1/296 H. 1017]

Haafidh Ibn Hajar said: “He is declared Thiqah by the Jumhoor”
[Hadi us-Saari P. 456; Taqreeb at-Tahdheeb: 1041]

Ibn Hajar said: “He is declared Thiqah by the Jumhoor”
[Fath al-Baari: 9/375 under H. 5266]

Al-Aynee said: “He is declared Thiqah by the Jumhoor”
[Umdat al-Qaari: 30/85]

Ibn al-Mulaqqin said: “There is a famous dispute on him, but the Majority is upon his Tawtheeq”
[Khulaasah al-Badar al-Muneer: 2/99 H. 1623]

Ibn Hajar said: “He is declared Thiqah by majority”
[Fath al-Baari: 10/150 under H. 5694]

Al-Manaawi said: “He is declared Thiqah by the Majority, and he is weakened by some due to his memory”
[Faydh al-Qadeer: 6/45 H. 8326]

Al-Nawawi said: “He is criticized by a group; however he is declared Thiqah by the Majority”
[Al-Majmoo Sharh al-Muhadhdhab: 1/370]

Ibn Hajar said: “He is Maqbool according to the Jumhoor”
[Al-Amaali al-Mutlaqah: 1/75]

Al-Iraaqi said: “He is weakened by the Jumhoor”
[Al-Taqiyeed wal Aydhaah P. 51]

I say: The truth about Shahr bin Hawshab is with Al-Nawawi that he is declared Thiqah by the Majority

Al-Zayla’ee said: “However, he is declared Thiqah by the Majority of Scholars…”
[Nasb ur-Raayah: 1/344]

Al-Aynee said: “… he is among those who are criticized, however he is declared Thiqah by the Majority of Scholars; and Muslim has taken evidence from him in his Saheeh; and the weakening of those who weakened him does not necessitate the rejection of his hadeeth…”
[Sharh Sunan Abi Dawood lil Aynee: 3/414-415; Also See, Umdat al-Qaari: 9/40]

Al-Haafidh Ibn Hajar said: “He is declared Thiqah by the Majority”
[Hadi us-Saari: P. 457]

Ibn Hajar al-Asqalaani said: “And he is Thiqah according to the Majority”
[Fath al-Baari: 10/140 under H. 5683]

Al-Haafidh said: “He is one of the Thiqah Thabat narrators, and he is declared Thiqah by the Jumhoor”
[Fath al-Baari: 1/419]

Ibn al-Mulaqqin said: “And the Majority – as said by Al-Nawawi in Sharh al-Muhadhdhab – has taken evidence from him”
[Khulaasah al-Badar al-Muneer: 87, 234; also see, Al-Talkhees al-Habeer: 1/84]

I (Shaykh Zubayr) say: The correct opinion is that he is weakened by the Jumhoor.

I (Raza) say: The saying of Ibn al-Mulaqqin is more correct.

Abdul Majeed bin Abdul Azeez bin Abi Rawwaad
Al-Busayri said: “However, he is declared Thiqah by the Jumhoor”
[Zawaaid Ibn Maajah: 1094]

Al-Sindhi said: “However, he is declared Thiqah by the Jumhoor”
[Haashiah as-Sindhi Ala Sunan Ibn Maajah: 1/340 H. 1094]

Al-Zayla’ee said: “And he is declared Thiqah by the Majority”
[Nasb ur-Raayah: 2/185]

Al-Nawawi said: “He is disputed upon; and the majority has declared him Thiqah; and Muslim has taken evidence from him in his Saheeh”
[Khulaasah al-Ahkaam: 2/735 H. 2571]

Ibn Iraaq al-Kinaani said: “The Jumhoor is upon his Tawtheeq”
[Tanzeeh ush-Sharee’ah: 2/372 H. 28]

Al-Bayhaqi said: “And Ikrimah is one of the Thiqah Thabat narrators according to the Majority of A’immah”
[Al-Sunan al-Kubra: 8/234]

Al-Busayri said: “And he has been declared Thiqah by the Jumhoor”
[Zawaaid Ibn Maajah: 2672]

Al-Suyooti said: “And he is declared Thiqah by the Jumhoor”
[Al-Haawi lil Fataawa: 2/104]

Ibn al-Mulaqqin said: “The Majority is upon taking evidence from it (i.e. from this Silsilah of chain) as said by Ibn as-Salaah in his Kalaam on al-Muhadhdhab”
[Khulaasah al-Badar al-Muneer: 85]

Al-Zayla’ee said: “And the Majority of People take evidence from the hadeeth of Amr bin Shu’ayb, when the narrator narrating from him is Thiqah…”
[Nasb ur-Raayah: 1/58]

Al-Haafidh Ibn Taymiyyah said: “And as for the A’immah of Islaam and the Jumhoor of Scholars, then they take evidence from the hadeeth of Amr bin Shu’ayb narrated from his Father from his Grandfather, when the narration is authentic up to him…”
[Majmoo Fataawa: 8/18]


Al-Haythami said: “And the Majority is upon his Tawtheeq”
[Majma az-Zawaaid: 1/26]

Al-Haafidh Ibn Hajar said: “And he is declared Thiqah by the Jumhoor”
[Fath al-Baari: 1/432]

Al-Faraj bin Fadaalah bin al-Nu’maan at-Tanookhi ash-Shaami
Al-Iraaqi said: “He is weakened by the Jumhoor”
[Takhreej al-Ihyaa: 3/374]

Al-Aynee said: “And the Jumhoor has declared Al-Qaasim bin Abdur Rahmaan Thiqah, and some have weakened him”
[Umdat al-Qaari: 7/146 H. 1103]

Al-Suyooti said: “And Qaza’ah is declared Thiqah by the Jumhoor”
[Al-Aali al-Masnoo’ah: 1/218]

Al-Haythami said: "And he is weakened by the Jumhoor"
[Majma az-Zawaaid: 6/245] 

Translator: Al-Haythami's opinion is more correct.

Al-Haythami said: “And the Majority is upon his Tawtheeq”
[Majma az-Zawaaid: 1/54]
And Al-Haythami also has a Marjooh saying in Majma az-Zawaaid
[8/202]

Al-Zayla’ee said: “The Majority is upon his Tawtheeq”
[Nasb ur-Raayah: 4/7]

Abdul Haqq al-Ashbaylee said: “He is declared Thiqah by a group, and weakened by others, and those who declared him Thiqah are the Majority”
[Al-Ahkaam ash-Sharee’ah al-Kubra: 1/79]

Al-Aynee said: “The criticism of Ibn al-Jawzee for Ibn Ishaaq is nothing for verily Ibn Ishaaq is from the Major Thiqah narrators according to the Jumhoor”
[Umdat al-Qaari: 7/270]

Muhammad bin Muslim bin Tadrus, Abu az-Zubayr al-Makki
Ibn Hajar said: “And he is declared Thiqah by the Jumhoor…”
[Fath al-Baari: 1/442]

Mu’aawiyah bin Yahya, Abu Mutee’ al-Atraabilisi ad-Dimashqi
Al-Haafidh al-Iraaqi said: “And the Jumhoor has declared him Thiqah”
[Zayl Meezaan al-I’tidaal: 1/193]

Al-Waleed bin Muslim ad-Dimashqi
Ibn Hajar said: “…And the Jumhoor has declared him Thiqah…”
[Fath al-Baari: 1/450]

Al-Mundhiri said: “And the Majority is upon his Tawtheeq”
[Al-Targheeb wal Tarheeb: 1/298 H. 1097]

Ibn Hajar said: “And the Jumhoor has declared him Thiqah”
[Fath al-Baari: 1/455]

 Translator’s Addition:
Al-Nawawi said: “The Jumhoor has declared him Thiqah”
[Al-Majmoo: 2/99]
 

No comments:

Post a Comment